Our Story

Miss American Pie is a Brooklyn based company, focused on building community and spreading Love, one pie at a time. It's about bringing people together, sharing ideas, community, and fellowship. We put our heart and soul into everything we bake. Using fresh fruit and quality ingredients, encased in an impossibly flaky, mouthwatering crust is what makes Miss American pies among the best in the business. Each pie is made with Love and hand-crafted to perfection. We are a small team, learning as we go, and growing as people in the process. 

After almost 5 years as a storefront cafe, Miss American Pie has closed its physical doors, and is now focused on pop-ups, holiday catering, and other events. Since our inception in 2019, our product offerings have expanded to include more than just desserts. We now offer options for catering weddings, as well as both family and corporate events. We offer high quality savory options for breakfast and lunch, along with our unrivaled pies and other desserts.

Fill out our catering form to find out more.