FAQ

1. What is the Signature Pie?

Our best seller by far, the Signature is our flaky, all-butter crust filled with the perfect combination of apples, peaches, and blueberries, topped with an oatmeal crumb and a beautiful lattice crust.

2. Do you make everything in the store?

Yes, everything is baked fresh daily, on premises.

3. Is that you in the logo?

Yes, that’s me.

4. Do you sell slices? Do you sell coffee? What else do you sell besides pie? 

We offer a variety of different baked goods and beverages. We sell sweet pies by the slice and whole, we also sell savory pies, sandwiches, breads, cookies, coffee, tea, and more. Check out our full takeout menu here.

5. Do you have indoor dining? 

Yes, we currently have indoor dining, as well as outdoor seating.

6. Do you sell whole pies? 

Yes, we sell whole pies by pre-order, as well as by walk-in.

7. I have an event I want to bring a pie to. Can I preorder a whole pie? 

Yes, we have a wide variety of whole pies, cookies, and pastries available for pre-order.

8. How do I place an order? 

Call us at 718-789-3747 or check out our pre-order/online store.

9. How far in advance do I need to place a pre-order? 

We require 24 hours notices for pre-orders. However, we do have a limited selection of whole pies available each day for walk-ins. Give us a call to see what’s available.

10. I have allergies or dietary restrictions. Can you accommodate? 

We offer several vegan and gluten-free options on our daily as well as our pre-order menu. We do our best to avoid cross contaminations of any common allergens, such as nuts, dairy, eggs, gluten, etc. However, all items are processed in the same kitchen with wheat, dairy ,eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, and soy.

11. Can I order an off-menu pie?

All of our recipes are thoroughly tested and vetted, and meticulously crafted. We do not offer adjustments to the recipes/flavors or off menu items. If you’d like us to make something that isn’t on our menu, give us a call and we may be able to develop a recipe or at least point you in the right direction.

12. Can you write on a pie? 

No, we cannot write messages on your whole pie orders.