Order Online
powered by BentoBox (opens in a new tab)
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Winter Pies

Winter Pies

These pies are available by pre-order seasonally.

Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.

FRUIT PIES
  • Pear and Lavender Crisp

    Pear and Lavender Crisp

    Our dairy-free crisp cookie crust, filled with sweet red pears flavored with a hint of lavender and topped with a flavorful oatmeal crumb.

    Also available in a gluten-free or standard crust.

CREAM PIES
  • Dark Chocolate Coconut Cream

    Dark Chocolate Coconut Cream

    A chocolate version of our dairy-free crust filled with rich, dark chocolate pudding and smeared with slightly sweetened whipped coconut cream, topped with lightly toasted coconut and freeze-dried cherries.

  • Peppermint Mocha Cream Pie

    Peppermint Mocha Cream Pie

    A cocoa mint cookie crust filled with espresso infused mocha pudding and topped with fresh peppermint whipped cream. A perfect holiday treat.

  • Chocolate Cherry Chiffon

    Chocolate Cherry Chiffon

    Our flaky, all-butter crust, layered with thick chocolate ganache, light, fluffy cherry cream and house-made tart cherry jam.

CUSTARD PIES
  • Cranberry Orange Tart

    Cranberry Orange Tart

    A sweet and spicy gingerbread all-butter crust, filled with a perfectly smooth, creamy, and tangy cranberry orange curd, topped with fresh, beautifully sugared cranberries and orange zest. A holiday jewel. Also available in gluten-free crust.