Order Online
powered by BentoBox (opens in a new tab)
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Fall Pies

Fall Pies

These pies are available by pre-order seasonally.

Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.

FRUIT PIES
  • Caramel Apple Pie

    Caramel Apple Pie

    A double portion of our flaky, all-butter crust filled with lusciously seasoned apples soaked in creamy caramel.

  • Cranberry Apple Crisp

    Cranberry Apple Crisp

    Choose from our flaky, all-butter crust, or a dairy-free or gluten-free version of our crisp cookie crust filled with a delectable combination of cranberries and apples, seasoned with orange and nutmeg and topped with a flavorful oatmeal crumb.

  • Dutch Apple Walnut

    Dutch Apple Walnut

    Our gluten-free crisp cookie crust filled with beautifully-seasoned creamed apples, and topped with a flavorful walnut streusel.

  • Bacon Lattice Apple Pie

    Bacon Lattice Apple Pie

    Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with lusciously seasoned apples and topped with a crispy bacon lattice! Available for special order on Father’s Day only. Also available in gluten-free crust.

CUSTARD PIES
  • Pumpkin Pie

    Pumpkin Pie

    Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with a perfectly seasoned and not-too-sweet pumpkin custard. For holiday orders, we top it with seasonal cutouts and candied cranberries.

  • Vegan Pumpkin Pie

    Vegan Pumpkin Pie

    A dairy-free version of our crisp cookie crust filled with a spicy pumpkin custard, then topped with freshly whipped coconut cream.

  • Sweet Potato Pie

    Sweet Potato Pie

    Choose from our flaky, all-butter crust, or our gluten-free butter cookie crust, filled with a creamy sweet potato custard. Add fresh whipped cream (optional) to finish it off.

  • Chocolate Pumpkin Chess Pie

    Chocolate Pumpkin Chess Pie

    Our flaky, all-butter crust, filled with rich, chocolatey pumpkin custard and topped with pumpkin spice whipped cream

    $50.00

CONFECTION PIES
  • Classic Pecan Pie

    Classic Pecan Pie

    Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with a classic combination of eggs, butter and sugar, and topped with toasted pecans. Another southern favorite. Also available in gluten-free option.

  • Double Chocolate Maple Pecan Pie

    Double Chocolate Maple Pecan Pie

    Our chocolate all-butter crust with a rich sticky filling featuring semisweet chocolate, real maple syrup, Cacao Maple Vodka, and packed to the brim with crunchy pecans. A chocoholic’s dream.